Abstract Title
Virtual Patients - how close to reality are they?

Authors

Hege Inga
Marcel Urrestri
Daniel Tolks
Claudia Kiessling

Theme

8II Mobile learning

INSTITUTION

Institute for Medical Education, LMU Munich

Background

 

Virtual Patients (VPs) are:

  • Suitable to teach clinical reasoning skills
  • Often well designed in terms of didactical, technical and content-related aspects.
  • As realistic and interactive as possible, e.g. by including videos and questions

Situation at LMU Munich:

  • 71 VPs in internal medicine/surgery are integrated into the medical curriculum at LMU Munich.
  • VPs deepen and complement face-to-face courses
  • Most VPs are NOT based on real patient stories

Figure 1: Example card of VP in CASUS® (click for full size)

 

Summary of Results
  • Over-representation of German academic VPs, no refugees, no unemployed VPs (see Details)
  • Elderly VPs underrepresented, "strange" peak at age 35-39 (see Figure 1 in details)
  • Data often not entered by VP authors (e.g. BMI, smoking, Handicap, Pre-medication)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 Common diseases in Germany

 VP Main diagnosis

 VP Medical history

1.

 Cardiovascular Diseases

 Injuries, Intoxication

 Cardiovascular Diseases

2.

 Injuries, Intoxications

 Cardiovascular Diseases

 Endocrinal & Metabolic Diseases

3.

 Gastro-intestinal Diseases

 Neoplasms

 Gastro-intestinal Diseases

4.

 Neoplasms

 Gastro-intestinal & Pulmonary  
 Diseases

 Pulmonary Diseases

Table 1: Most common diseases in Germany in comparison to diseases covered in VPs

 

Age (see Fig 2 in Details) 46.3 yrs   43.9 yrs
Nationality 97% German    91% German
Occupation
 
33% Academic
0% Unemployed
 

21% Academic
6.5% Unemployed

Female:Male 50:50   ~ 50:50
BMI (Details) 47% norm-weighted   46% norm-weighted
Smoker 20%   22%
Handicap 4%   7%
       
       
       

 

Summary of Work

Pilotstudy:
We analyzed the 71 VPs integrated into the internal medicine/surgery curriculum at LMU Munich concerning the following aspects:

  • Age, Sex, occupation, nationality of VP
  • BMI, smoking, handicap
  • Medical history, main diagnosis

These data were compared to statistical data of the German population1

Conclusion

Conclusions from this Pilot study:

  • Difficult to get reliable data about patients in Germany.
  • More guidance for authors necessary, to include basic data (e.g. BMI, pre-medication,...).
  • Revise VPs based on the results.

Outlook:

  • Main study on VPs in an European context planned
  • Include additional data related to patient perspective and communication (based on Kenny et al.)
  • Further investigate influence of creation process
References
  1. www.gbe-bund.de (data from 2012)

  2. Kenny NP, Beagan BL (2004). The patient as text: a challenge for problem-based learning. Med Educ 38:1071-9

Background
Summary of Results

Figure 2: % of VPs and real patients depending on age.

Summary of Work
Conclusion
References
Send ePoster Link