Seventy-six percent reported their overall experience was positive or strongly positive; 95% considered themselves adequately or excellently supported by their immediate senior, and 93% by both their SpRs and Consultants. Experience of elective surgical admissions was modest, but 91% of doctors clerked on average more than >5 emergency patients per week, and 78% gained operating theatre exposure. Procedural skills were also gained (86% performing ABGs, 73% suturing, and 57% performing minor surgery). Scholarly activity and academic interests were also well supported, with 88% reporting the opportunity to participate in audit projects or research. In contrast 45% of doctors were of the opinion that there was too little formal teaching provided. Opinion on EWTD was divided, with 68% in support of the restrictions. There were no significant differences in educational experiences relative to surgical specialty interest (p=0.98), and 91% would recommend their job to a final year student.

Overall Surgical F1 jobs were well supported, providing a wealth of clinical and academic experience.

More evidence is needed to justify reduction and conversion of surgical F1 posts into primary care.